America Rules the Waves. But for How Long? -Interview

Comments Off on America Rules the Waves. But for How Long? -Interview

America Rules the Waves. But for How Long? -Interview

U.S. Navy file photo

By Tobin Harshaw (Bloomberg View) — China builds fake islands in the South China Sea. Russia fires missiles into Syria from the Mediterranean and Caspian Seas. North Korea launches ballistic missiles into the Sea of Japan. The U.S. orders three — three! — aircraft carrier strike groups to the Western Pacific in response. Houthi rebels shoot rockets at U.S. ships off Yemen. Pacific nations go on a submarine-buying binge. India and China start constructing their first homemade aircraft carriers. Pirates return to the waters off East Africa.

Buy on Amazon: Sea Power: The History and Geopolitics of the World’s Oceans

You’d be forgiven for thinking that control of high seas is becoming more vital than any time since World War II. Which makes it the perfect moment for an authoritative new book on the role of sea power in shaping human civilization across the globe and across the ages.

Into the breach steps James Stavridis (JS), a retired four-star admiral and former supreme allied commander of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. His new book, “Sea Power: The History and Geopolitics of the World’s Oceans,” is a breezy yet comprehensive overview of the topic, as well as a sort of sailor’s log and meditation on the power of the Great Blue. I decided a talk with Stavridis, now dean of the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University, could help put the rising tensions on the world’s waterways into perspective. Here is an edited transcript of our interview.

TH: Admiral Stavridis, before opening the book, I assumed it would be a technical treatise on naval strategy, a sort of 21st-century update of Alfred Thayer Mahan’s epochal “Influence of Seapower Upon History.” Instead, it’s a very personal, impressionistic book; we learn as much about the adventures of neophyte Midshipman James Stavridis in the 1970s as about the Battles of Salamis, Trafalgar and Midway.

JS: There will be other books, and I have in mind to expand on Mahan for the current age. But it took me 40 years to write about my life at sea, and I thought back on that and reflected on it in relation to today’s world, with the return of great-power politics. I wanted to put the reader into the captain’s chair.

TH: You warn that the U.S. and China have to avoid the so-called Thucydides Trap, where miscalculation of an enemy’s intentions can lead to an otherwise avoidable war. Given China’s island-building and other aggressions, how can the U.S. and regional partners push back without pushing too far?

JS: First thing, China plays the long game. They are not concerned with 10 or even 50 years into the future. They are looking centuries ahead. We need to match that mindset. The Chinese feel that they will inevitably dominate Asia and play from a position of confidence. They don’t lunge for the ball, they pull at all levers: economic, political, historical and military.

The appropriate response for the U.S. is to maintain itself as the pre-eminent Pacific power, not just militarily but through economic and geopolitical leadership. It is a region without a NATO, and the U.S. withdrawal from the Trans-Pacific Partnership was a giant miss for us. That makes it more vital to strengthen individual military relations with friendly nations.

TH: You’re a former military commander of NATO, which many Americans think of as a ground force. But as you point out, in the Cold War, the Baltic Sea and the GIUK Gap were tense places. With Vladimir Putin getting very aggressive at sea as well as on land, what can the alliance do in response?

JS: Both the Baltic and Black Seas are inland lakes in Russia’s eyes. NATO needs to deploy and conduct joint exercises repetitively; it can’t just be the U.S. In the Baltic, operating with non-members — the Finns and the Swedes — as well as Denmark, Germany and Britain is incredibly important. Same thing in the Black Sea, with members Bulgaria, Romania and Turkey and non-members Georgia and Ukraine.

However, these are relatively small, contained waters, so the possibility of a dustup is high. We need to adhere closely to “incidents at sea” agreements with Russia and operate in ways that can deconflict. And we need to use our land-based air in conjunction with the ships, because the Russians will. The overall strategy, at sea and land, is to reassure allies that we will be there in a crisis and to keep Vladimir Putin from “leaning in” with hybrid war, as he did in Ukraine.

TH: How about in the Mediterranean?

JS: In terms of refugees, both from the war in Syria and from Libya, we are only treating the symptoms, all the effects of the so-called Arab Spring. Right now, the Jordanians, Lebanese and Turks, with European money, have opened respectable refugee camps. But if that becomes unsustainable, if the tens of millions of displaced people see an opportunity to cross to Europe, they will. NATO has 800-plus ships and a fundamental role in all this, but we can be insufficiently mindful that the Med is an ocean highway.

TH: You have a surprising prediction: that the 21st century will be more about the Indian Ocean and its appendages — the Arabian Gulf and Red Sea — than about the Pacific or Atlantic. How do you see this playing out, and what are the biggest opportunities and risks for the U.S. and its allies?

JS: The biggest opportunity in geopolitics right now is the rise of India. By mid-century, it will be more populous and younger than China. It is centrally located, on both the continent and the sea. The ocean also abuts Africa, the fastest-growing place in the world. Indonesia will be the fourth-largest nation.

We should be doing everything we can to partner with India. Yes, there is corruption and weak infrastructure. But it is a democracy and cohesive, and the elites speak English, plus a cultural affinity built by the British Raj.

As for the Gulf, oil may become less important as the world switches to sustainables and other forms of energy. But the geopolitics, the fraught relationship between Iran and the Sunni states, will continue to create tensions and challenges for us.

TH: All this means the U.S. ability to maintain a forward presence at sea will be further stretched. Our main tool for this has long been the aircraft carrier. Yet many people feel that the new Ford Class supercarriers are hugely vulnerable and no longer as important to projecting power. Do you disagree?

JS: I think that is exactly half right. I think they are more vulnerable than ever because offensive weapons are better than ever: submarines are quieter, cruise missiles are more accurate, there is a growing ability to target from space. And the limited range of the new F-35 fighter is problem. It will mean having to integrate long-range, land-based air with the tactical punch from the flight deck.

Yet the carrier strike group is still the premier flexible power-projection option. It can cover 700 to 750 miles a day. And the carriers are strongly protected by nuclear submarines and Arleigh Burke-class destroyers with Aegis missile-defense systems. If we went to war at sea, we would take some hits — but I would still bet on the carrier.

TH: When you describe the famed entry of Commodore Perry into Tokyo Bay in 1853, you call it an early example of what we now call “soft power.” That’s not a concept the Trump administration has a lot of respect for. What are the main ways you feel the military, and the Navy in particular, could use soft power to effect today?

JS: In my career I had many opportunities to deploy aircraft carriers, but I felt the most effective were soft-power operations, and it’s the flexibility of maritime operations that made it work. Sending them, as well as our two hospital ships, the Comfort and Mercy, which can do hundreds of thousands of patient treatments on a single deployment, are the ultimate in disaster relief and humanitarian aid. For example, the carrier Ronald Reagan was the first foreign responder to the tidal wave and nuclear disaster at Fukushima, Japan, in 2011. That strike group provided electricity, refueling, medical care, etc. Same thing for the Indian Ocean in 2004, Haiti in 2010.

It’s not just emergencies. Engineers from our large-deck amphibious ships can come ashore in poor nations and install wells, build clinics and schools. Sailors set up health facilities, visit orphanages, run sports clinics. The Navy can be a symbol of U.S. confidence and compassion.

TH: Last, one of your other big warnings is about environmental degradation — both in terms of climate change and, more specifically, ocean pollution and destruction of fisheries etc. What needs to be done now to turn things around?

JS: Donald Trump’s decision to pull the U.S. out of the Paris agreement is a huge blow. Voluntary, international cooperation on emissions control is the way forward, and now that is in question. There are a lot of international organizations that work on fisheries, scientific monitoring, deal with pollution and the like, but they are mostly under the United Nations umbrella. And strengthening them under Trump will be tougher.

In the U.S., we need better interagency cooperation: all cabinet-level and other organizations — Treasury, Justice Department, Coast Guard — working together to think through our regulatory regimes, share data, and reach a common understanding of how to go after lawbreakers. Oceans are the biggest crime scene in the world.

But above all, we need better public-private cooperation. You cannot solve this globally without working with the companies that move 95 percent of the world’s good across the ocean highway. It would be like developing a cyber-defense strategy without talking to Microsoft or Google. People call the Amazon the “lungs of the earth,” but it’s really the oceans. And if we cannot count on sustainable oceans, our future is bleak.

Tobin Harshaw writes editorials on national security, education and food for Bloomberg View. He was an editor with the op-ed page of the New York Times and the paper’s letters editor.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

© 2017 Bloomberg L.P

Comments are closed.

Découvrez les avantages de MadCasino

Dans le monde des casinos en ligne, MadCasino se distingue par ses offres attrayantes et ses services de qualité. Que vous soyez un joueur débutant ou un parieur aguerri, vous trouverez ici une variété de jeux qui sauront satisfaire toutes vos envies. Les machines à sous, les jeux de table et les options de paris en direct sont tous disponibles pour vous offrir une expérience de jeu inégalée. De plus, le casino propose régulièrement des bonus qui permettent d'augmenter vos chances de gagner, vous offrant ainsi une excellente opportunité de maximiser vos gains.

En matière de sécurité, MadCasino est un nom de confiance. Il est entièrement licencié et régulé, ce qui garantit un environnement de jeu sûr et équitable. Les joueurs peuvent se concentrer sur leur expérience de jeu sans se soucier des problèmes de sécurité. Les transactions financières sont également sécurisées grâce à des technologies de pointe.

Les jeux proposés par MadCasino sont issus des développeurs les plus réputés de l'industrie, vous assurant des graphismes époustouflants et des mécaniques de jeu innovantes. Les joueurs peuvent également profiter d'une expérience de jeu en direct qui simule l'atmosphère d'un casino terrestre, tout en restant dans le confort de leur maison.

Enfin, la plateforme de MadCasino est optimisée pour les appareils mobiles, permettant aux joueurs de parier à tout moment et de n'importe où. Que vous soyez sur votre smartphone ou votre tablette, l'accès à vos jeux préférés n'a jamais été aussi simple. Ne manquez pas l'opportunité de découvrir ce casino exceptionnel.

Les offres de Cresus Casino

Cresus Casino est un autre acteur majeur dans le domaine des jeux en ligne, offrant des promotions généreuses et une vaste sélection de jeux. Les joueurs peuvent profiter d'une expérience de jeu enrichissante grâce aux nombreux bonus disponibles, qui sont conçus pour attirer tant les nouveaux utilisateurs que les joueurs réguliers. Ces avantages permettent non seulement de prolonger votre temps de jeu, mais aussi d'augmenter vos chances de gains conséquents.

Le casino se distingue également par sa ludothèque impressionnante, comprenant une sélection variée de machines à sous, de jeux de table et de jeux en direct. Les clients peuvent choisir parmi des titres populaires et appréciés, ainsi que des nouveautés qui enrichissent constamment l'offre. L'interface utilisateur est conviviale, rendant la navigation sur la plateforme fluide et agréable.

En termes de sécurité, Cresus Casino assure à ses joueurs un environnement de jeu fiable. La plateforme utilise des protocoles de sécurité avancés pour protéger les données personnelles et financières des utilisateurs. Cela permet aux joueurs de se sentir en sécurité tout en jouant à leurs jeux préférés.

Avec un service client réactif et professionnel, Cresus Casino s'assure que toutes vos questions et préoccupations sont traitées rapidement. Que ce soit pour des questions concernant les bonus, les retraits ou les jeux, vous bénéficierez d'une assistance rapide et efficace.

Explorez Nine Casino et ses avantages

Dans l'univers des casinos en ligne, Nine Casino a su se faire une place de choix grâce à son approche innovante et à ses nombreux avantages pour les joueurs. Les utilisateurs peuvent s'attendre à une expérience de jeu enrichissante, avec des bonus attractifs qui sont régulièrement mis à jour. Ces offres sont une excellente façon de découvrir de nouveaux jeux tout en maximisant votre potentiel de gain.

La plateforme de Nine Casino est riche en options de jeux, allant des machines à sous aux jeux de table, en passant par le live casino. Chaque jeu est conçu pour offrir une expérience immersive grâce à des graphismes de haute qualité et des fonctionnalités innovantes. Les parieurs peuvent profiter de sessions de jeu captivantes, comme s'ils étaient dans un véritable casino.

La sécurité est une priorité pour Nine Casino, qui utilise des technologies de cryptage avancées pour protéger les informations de ses joueurs. Cela garantit un environnement de jeu sûr et fiable, permettant aux utilisateurs de se concentrer sur ce qu'ils aiment le plus : jouer.

Enfin, le service clientèle fourni par Nine Casino est exceptionnel, avec des agents disponibles pour répondre à toutes vos questions et résoudre vos problèmes. Vous pourrez ainsi jouer en toute tranquillité, sachant que votre satisfaction est au cœur de leurs préoccupations.

Profitez de l'expérience Lucky31

Lucky31 est un casino en ligne qui se distingue par son approche orientée vers le joueur, offrant une multitude d'options de jeux et des bonus généreux. Que vous soyez amateur de machines à sous ou passionné de jeux de table, vous trouverez une large sélection pour satisfaire toutes vos envies de jeu. Les promotions fréquentes permettent aux joueurs de prolonger leur expérience tout en augmentant leurs chances de gains.

La convivialité de la plateforme de Lucky31 est l'un de ses plus grands atouts. Les joueurs peuvent naviguer facilement entre les différents jeux, et l'interface est conçue pour être intuitive, quel que soit le niveau d'expérience de l'utilisateur. De plus, le casino est entièrement optimisé pour les appareils mobiles, ce qui permet de parier où que vous soyez.

En matière de sécurité, Lucky31 prend les préoccupations des joueurs très au sérieux. Le casino est agréé et régulé, garantissant un environnement de jeu équitable et sécurisé. Les joueurs peuvent ainsi se concentrer sur leur expérience de jeu sans se soucier des risques liés à la sécurité.

Pour ceux qui recherchent un support client efficace, Lucky31 offre un service réactif et professionnel. Que ce soit pour des questions sur les bonus, les jeux ou les paiements, vous aurez accès à une assistance de qualité, vous garantissant une expérience de jeu fluide et agréable.